Despite the condition and configuration, their client could see the potential. “Our biggest goal was to bring the house back to a single-family residence,” says Shuster. “We were very fortunate to save the original staircase and open it back up to the first floor. A lot of work was done to create a layout that was both functional and beautiful. And, we wanted to make sure and feature as much existing historical charm as possible.”
The vinyl siding and the rotting roof had to go. In came elements like cement board and trim, along with new columns, to refresh the exterior. Interior original features, like the fireplace tile, mantels, and pocket doors were restored; windows with a distinctive X pattern were restored and replicated throughout. A new layout made to accommodate a single family includes a primary suite and a guest suite. Classic updates to the kitchen and bathrooms feature materials that complement the original historic charm.
Additional enhancements stand out. “I think the rear elevation is such an amazing transformation. The removal of the unsafe deck at the second story and weird protruding laundry allowed for a really beautiful and simple design at the back of the house,” says Shuster. “An American Foursquare isn’t meant to be showy or overly detailed. Having a more simple design at the back is a much better match to the overall home’s design and flow.”
As she explains, “American Foursquare homes are often the epitome of a family home. The rooms are generous; there aren’t too many hallways. Spaces open to one another in a clear and orderly fashion. But there remains the opportunity for privacy from room to room.”
Now this fine specimen that already had a great location has reclaimed its original charm. “For those looking for spaces that offer a clear order, American Foursquares deliver,” says Shuster. “And at the exterior, the clean lines of a proper two-story home with a roof that isn’t too domineering means that these generally large homes don’t overpower their neighbors.” Practical, thoughtful, and beautiful to boot.
Planning Stages
Heather Shuster shares some things to consider before a renovation.
Ask the Questions. Taking on a home improvement or renovation project requires a lot of research and decision making, says Shuster. “What work needs to be done? How will my family’s life be affected? How much can I spend? Who will I hire to complete the work?”
Scope It Out. One question that often comes up during the initial research phase is, “Should I do the work all at once or complete it one project at a time?” she says. “In the industry, the extent of work being done is what we call scope. Extensive projects are considered large scope. Less extensive projects are considered small scope. So, how much work you get done at a time is a matter of scope.”
Make It Personal. Lastly, “Determining the scope of your project will help you make the best decisions for you and your family,” says Shuster. “Deciding between one large renovation project (i.e. large scope) or several smaller projects (i.e. small scope) should be based on your family’s current lifestyle and needs.”
